Licensed vs Unofficial College Apparel: What’s the Difference?

By |
Licensed vs Unofficial College Apparel

Search for a university hoodie and you’ll find three kinds of products: officially licensed merchandise, unofficial designs, and outright knock-offs. They can look similar on a screen, but they’re not the same thing. Here’s what each one means, so you can choose with your eyes open.

Key facts

  • Official: made by a licensee the school has approved, using its trademarks, with a royalty paid to the school
  • The label: many US colleges license through CLC, whose products carry an “Officially Licensed Collegiate Product” hologram
  • Unofficial: designs not approved by, licensed by or affiliated with the school
  • Knock-offs: copies of a school’s logos, seals or mascots without permission
  • The legal test in the US: whether buyers are likely to be confused about who made or approved a product

What “officially licensed” means

Universities own trademarks: their names in certain forms, logos, seals, mascots and slogans. To sell merchandise using those marks, a company signs a licensing agreement with the school or its licensing agent. At the University of Texas, for example, licensees must submit every design for approval before production and report their sales and royalties every month. Many US schools work through CLC, the licensing company formed when Learfield Licensing Partners and IMG College combined, and licensed products carry its “Officially Licensed Collegiate Product” hologram label. Part of what you pay goes back to the school.

If supporting the school financially matters to you, or you want its official logo or seal, official merchandise is the way to go. Look for the hologram or buy from the school’s own store.

What “unofficial” means

Unofficial apparel isn’t approved by the school and doesn’t pay it a royalty. It should never use the school’s logo, seal, mascot or other official artwork. Expressionize’s college and university range is unofficial: the designs are our own original typography and layouts, they don’t reproduce logos, crests or seals, and our collection pages and FAQ say they aren’t licensed by, endorsed by or affiliated with any school.

The appeal of unofficial apparel is choice: a wider range of schools (including smaller ones that rarely get official merchandise), more sizes, and a consistent style across schools.

Why “no logo” isn’t the whole story

US trademark law asks a broader question than “did you copy the logo?” It asks whether buyers are likely to be confused about who made or approved a product. In Board of Supervisors for Louisiana State University v. Smack Apparel Co. (5th Cir. 2008), the court found that unlicensed shirts infringed four universities’ trademarks even though they didn’t use the schools’ names or logos, because they combined the schools’ colors with other references to the schools. The court noted that buyers expect university merchandise to be licensed.

That’s why clear disclosure matters. An unofficial product should say plainly that it’s unofficial and unaffiliated, so nobody buys it thinking it’s the real thing. Rules also differ from country to country, which matters for a store that sells in the US, Canada, the UK, the EU and Australia.

How to tell them apart when you shop

  • Look for the hologram or licensing statement. Official US collegiate products usually carry one.
  • Read the product description. A responsible unofficial seller tells you it isn’t affiliated with the school.
  • Check the artwork. If a cheap product reproduces an official seal or mascot exactly, be wary: that’s the mark of a knock-off.

Which should you buy?

If you want the school’s official marks, or you want your purchase to support the school, buy official. If you want an original design, a school that’s hard to find, or a bigger size range, an honest unofficial design is a reasonable choice, as long as the seller is upfront about what it is. For more, read University and College Branded Garments: 7 Factors to Consider.

This article explains general concepts and is not legal advice.

Sources